<< Chapter < Page Chapter >> Page >

Important successes in nanotechnology

In addition to the criticism of Drexler's vision of molecular manufacturing, three important developments thatwere independent of Drexler's paper helped turn nanotechnology into this broad field, today. First, the Scanning Tunneling Microscope(STM) was invented by Binnig and Rohrer in 1981.

1981-Invention of STM, Image From Steven Sibener,<http://sibener-group.uchicago.edu/facilities.html>
With this technology, individual atoms could be clearly identified for the first time. Despite its limitations (only conducting materials),this breakthrough was essential for the development of the field of nanotechnology because what had been previously concepts were nowwithin view and testable. Some of these limitations in microscopy were eliminated through the 1986 invention of the Atomic Force Microscope.
1986-Invention of AFM, image from Mike Tiner,<http://www.cnm.utexas.edu/AFM.HTM>
Using contact to create an image, this microscope could imagenon-conducting materials such as organic molecules. This invention was integral for the study of carbon buckyballs, discovered at Rice in 1985-6.[15]
1985-Buckyball discovered at Rice University by Smalley et al. Image from Stephen Bond,<http://femto.cs.uiuc.edu/~sbond/reports/c60c60qm1/buckyball.jpg>
Ultimately, with these two achievements, nanotechnology could develop through the scientific method rather than through the conceptual andthus untestable visions of Drexler.

This overall trend created by advancements in microscopy is illustrated through Don Eigler's revolutionary"stunt" at IBM. Here, he manipulated individual Xenon atoms on a Nickel surface to form the letters "IBM."

1989-First atomic manipulation at IBM by Don Eigler. Figure 10-Almaden Research Center,<http://www.almaden.ibm.com/vis/stm/atomo.html>
With the microscopy technology that was invented in the early to mideighties, Eigler and his research team advanced the field of nanotechnology by seeking to simply manipulate atoms. Thus, whileDrexler was conceiving sensationalized possibilities of "universal assemblers," Eigler focused his nanotech research on the realistic andattainable level that Smalley presented in his argument with Drexler. From this "stunt," nanotech research followed Eigler's pathand therefore strayed away from Drexler's original vision. Because nanotechnology was viewed at this level, the field soon encompassedboth practical manufacturing and non-manufacturing activities as Drexler's ideas were put aside.

Conclusion

While nanotechnology came into existence through Feynman's and then Drexler's vision of molecularmanufacturing, the field has evolved in the 21st century to largely include research in chemistry and materials science as well asmolecular engineering. As evidenced by Smalley's debate, this evolution is partly a response to the criticism of Drexler's views inboth Engines of Creation and the Foresight Institute. Thus, in regards to the development of nanotechnology inthe present, Drexler's vision can be viewed as an indirect influence through the sheer interest and subsequent criticism that he created inthe field. As Toumey argues, Drexler and therefore Feynman did not have a direct role in the three most important breakthroughs innanotechnology, the invention of the STM, the invention of the AFM, and the first manipulation of atoms [16]. Instead, Drexler, through Molecular Manufacturing and Engines of Creation, brought scientistsfrom all over the world to the brand new field. Consequently, criticism for Drexler's vision was established by researchers such asDr. Smalley. Through this reevaluation and the parallel breakthroughs in microscope technology, nanotechnology as a scientific field wasestablished in a way that diverged from Drexler's original vision of molecular manufacturing. This divergence is illustrated through thecontrasting goals of the government's National Nanotechnology Initiative (see "Important Links") and Drexler's ForesightInstitute. As a result, a thorough grasp of this early history is integral to understanding the development and definition of both therealities and potential of nanotechnology, today. Whereas Drexler created interest in the field but also sensationally outlined ananotech revolution, researchers around the world have brought the nanotechnology that Drexler first envisioned to a more realistic andattainable level. All in all, today, the goal for nanotech research is not to immediately create billions of assemblers that willrevolutionize our world but rather to explore the manufacturing and non-manufacturing aspects of nanotechnology, through a combination ofchemistry, materials science, and molecular engineering.17Though places such as Drexler's Foresight Institute remain, academicinstitutions such as Rice University stay away from Drexler's sensationalized vision of nanotechnology as molecularmanufacturing. This divergence is epitomized by the contrasting goals of the U.S government's National Nanotechnology Initiative and theForesight Institute.

Discussion questions

  • What is your take on Toumey's argument against the influence of Feynman's vision? Do you believe that he has it right or do youthink that Feynman had a more direct influence on future discoveries? Is his evidence enough?
  • In his 2004 paper in the Institute of Physics journal Nanotechnology , Drexler slay the grey goo myth he created in Engines of Creation. Is this indicative of a general trend of errorsin Drexler's sensationalized vision of molecular manufacturing? Or is this an honest miscalculation in an otherwise plausible theory?

References

[1] Wikipedia, There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom,<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plenty_of_Room_at_the_Bottom>

[2]Richard Feynman, There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom, Zyvex,<http://www.zyvex.com/nanotech/feynman.html>

[3]Chris Toumey, Apostolic Succession,<http://pr.caltech.edu/periodicals/EandS/articles/LXVIII1_2/Feynman.pdf>

[4]Wikipedia, Eric Drexler,<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K._Eric_Drexler>

[5] Source?

[6]Eric Drexler, Molecular Manufacturing,<http://www.imm.org/PNAS.html>

[7] Ibid.

[8] Wikipedia, Eric Drexler,<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K._Eric_Drexler>

[9]Michael Berry, The Creator,<http://www.sff.net/people/mberry/nano.htm>

[10] Ibid.

[11] Foresight Institute, About the Foresight Institute,<http://www.foresight.org/about/index.html>

[12] Chris Toumey, Apostolic Succession,<http://pr.caltech.edu/periodicals/EandS/articles/LXVIII1_2/Feynman.pdf>

[13] Buam, Rudy. Nanotechnology: Drexler and Smalley make the case for and against‘molecularassemblers.' Point Counterpoint, Vol.81, number 48, pp.37-41. Chemical and Engineering news. 2003.

[14] Ibid

15Foresight Institute,<http://www.foresight.org/UTF/Unbound_LBW/chapt_4.html>

[16] Chris Toumey, Apostolic Succession,<http://pr.caltech.edu/periodicals/EandS/articles/LXVIII1_2/Feynman.pdf>

Questions & Answers

how does Neisseria cause meningitis
Nyibol Reply
what is microbiologist
Muhammad Reply
what is errata
Muhammad
is the branch of biology that deals with the study of microorganisms.
Ntefuni Reply
What is microbiology
Mercy Reply
studies of microbes
Louisiaste
when we takee the specimen which lumbar,spin,
Ziyad Reply
How bacteria create energy to survive?
Muhamad Reply
Bacteria doesn't produce energy they are dependent upon their substrate in case of lack of nutrients they are able to make spores which helps them to sustain in harsh environments
_Adnan
But not all bacteria make spores, l mean Eukaryotic cells have Mitochondria which acts as powerhouse for them, since bacteria don't have it, what is the substitution for it?
Muhamad
they make spores
Louisiaste
what is sporadic nd endemic, epidemic
Aminu Reply
the significance of food webs for disease transmission
Abreham
food webs brings about an infection as an individual depends on number of diseased foods or carriers dully.
Mark
explain assimilatory nitrate reduction
Esinniobiwa Reply
Assimilatory nitrate reduction is a process that occurs in some microorganisms, such as bacteria and archaea, in which nitrate (NO3-) is reduced to nitrite (NO2-), and then further reduced to ammonia (NH3).
Elkana
This process is called assimilatory nitrate reduction because the nitrogen that is produced is incorporated in the cells of microorganisms where it can be used in the synthesis of amino acids and other nitrogen products
Elkana
Examples of thermophilic organisms
Shu Reply
Give Examples of thermophilic organisms
Shu
advantages of normal Flora to the host
Micheal Reply
Prevent foreign microbes to the host
Abubakar
they provide healthier benefits to their hosts
ayesha
They are friends to host only when Host immune system is strong and become enemies when the host immune system is weakened . very bad relationship!
Mark
what is cell
faisal Reply
cell is the smallest unit of life
Fauziya
cell is the smallest unit of life
Akanni
ok
Innocent
cell is the structural and functional unit of life
Hasan
is the fundamental units of Life
Musa
what are emergency diseases
Micheal Reply
There are nothing like emergency disease but there are some common medical emergency which can occur simultaneously like Bleeding,heart attack,Breathing difficulties,severe pain heart stock.Hope you will get my point .Have a nice day ❣️
_Adnan
define infection ,prevention and control
Innocent
I think infection prevention and control is the avoidance of all things we do that gives out break of infections and promotion of health practices that promote life
Lubega
Heyy Lubega hussein where are u from?
_Adnan
en français
Adama
which site have a normal flora
ESTHER Reply
Many sites of the body have it Skin Nasal cavity Oral cavity Gastro intestinal tract
Safaa
skin
Asiina
skin,Oral,Nasal,GIt
Sadik
How can Commensal can Bacteria change into pathogen?
Sadik
How can Commensal Bacteria change into pathogen?
Sadik
all
Tesfaye
by fussion
Asiina
what are the advantages of normal Flora to the host
Micheal
what are the ways of control and prevention of nosocomial infection in the hospital
Micheal
what is inflammation
Shelly Reply
part of a tissue or an organ being wounded or bruised.
Wilfred
what term is used to name and classify microorganisms?
Micheal Reply
Binomial nomenclature
adeolu
Got questions? Join the online conversation and get instant answers!
Jobilize.com Reply

Get Jobilize Job Search Mobile App in your pocket Now!

Get it on Google Play Download on the App Store Now




Source:  OpenStax, Nanotechnology: content and context. OpenStax CNX. May 09, 2007 Download for free at http://cnx.org/content/col10418/1.1
Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google Inc.

Notification Switch

Would you like to follow the 'Nanotechnology: content and context' conversation and receive update notifications?

Ask